Sydney has no shortage of pizza. But the best pizza in Sydney right now tends to share a few things: quality dough rested properly, a sauce that actually tastes like tomatoes, and toppings that don’t slide off mid-bite. We put together this list based on what locals are actually ordering — not who has the best PR team.
What We Looked For
Not every pizza is worth the detour. Before diving into the list, here’s the criteria we used:
Dough Quality
Proper resting time, the right flour, and a base that’s crispy without being dry — or chewy without being dense.
Sauce Depth
A good tomato base is simple, but it takes time to do properly. We’re looking for flavour, not just acidity.
Topping Balance
Enough toppings to cover the base, not so many they steam the dough. Cheese coverage matters more than cheese volume.
Value for Size
Sydney pizza prices vary wildly. We factored in portion size relative to price — a $30 pizza should actually feed two people.
Delivery Integrity
For delivery picks, we tested whether the pizza arrives in the same condition it left the kitchen — box design, drive time, packaging.
Consistency
A great pizza once is luck. Great pizza every time is a system. We weight repeat visits over one-off experiences.
The 7 Best Pizza Places in Sydney (2026)
⭐ #1 Pick — Best OverallMade In Italy
Made In Italy has been doing Roman-style pizza in Sydney since 2000 — well before it became trendy. Their base is the standout: thin, crispy, and properly charred at the edges, with a dough that’s been rested to give it real structure. The XL round pizzas are genuinely XL — one pizza comfortably feeds two, which makes the pricing rational compared to most Sydney competitors charging $28–34 for a 10-inch.
The Americana is the signature: tomato, mozzarella, smoked ham, mushrooms, American cheese, and Italian sausage. It’s the pizza that keeps people coming back. The Hot Roman Honey Pizza — drizzled with chilli honey post-bake — has developed its own cult following. Sauces are slow-cooked in-house rather than poured from a can, which you can taste.
Four Sydney locations (Alexandria, Annandale, Pyrmont, CBD), all with delivery. Free delivery on orders over $50. If you’re ordering for a group or office, they handle catering from 10 to 200+ people.
Best for: delivery, group orders, office catering, family dinners, people who want a proper Roman pizza rather than a Neapolitan-style wet-centred pie.
“25 years in, and the Americana is still the best pizza we’ve had in Sydney.”
- #2 — Best Neapolitan
Via Napoli
Via Napoli is the go-to for proper Neapolitan pizza in Sydney — soft, pillowy crust with a leopard-spotted char from the wood-fired oven. The Margherita here is one of the cleanest in the city: San Marzano tomatoes, fior di latte, fresh basil. The wet centre divides opinion but that’s classic Neapolitan. If you’re a purist, this is your spot.
Best for: dine-in, classic Italian pizza traditionalists, date nights.
- #3 — Best Wood-Fired Neighbourhood Pizza
Matteo’s Pizza
Matteo’s sits in the neighbourhood-local category — unpretentious, consistent, and reasonably priced. The wood-fired oven gives the base a distinctive smokiness that sets it apart from gas-oven competitors. Good range of classic Italian toppings, and the pasta sides are worth adding to your order.
Best for: casual dinners, families, couples who want a no-fuss local.
- #4 — Best for a Full Italian Meal
Fratelli Fresh
Fratelli Fresh is less of a pizzeria and more of a full Italian restaurant that does pizza well. The pizza is solid — thin-crust Roman style with well-sourced ingredients — but the real draw is the broader Italian menu, the antipasto selection, and the wine list. Good for groups who can’t decide between pasta and pizza (order both).
Best for: groups, business lunches, occasions where you want a full Italian spread rather than just pizza.
- #5 — Best Inner West Slice Shop
A Slice of Italy (Alexandria)
A Slice of Italy in Alexandria does what its name says — pizza by the slice, Roman-style, ready to go. The tray pizzas are baked throughout the day and sold fresh. Great for a quick lunch or late-afternoon snack. The variety rotates, so regulars check what’s on the board before committing.
Best for: quick lunches, takeaway, people who want a single slice rather than a whole pizza.
- #6 — Biggest Pizzas in Sydney
Criniti’s
Criniti’s built their brand around scale — their pizzas are famously large, and the Darling Harbour location is a Sydney institution for big group dinners. The pizza leans toward crowd-pleasing rather than artisan, but the size-to-price ratio is hard to argue with when you’re feeding eight people.
Best for: large groups, special occasion dinners, people who measure pizza by diameter.
- #7 — Best Late-Night Delivery
Epic Pizza
Epic Pizza fills the late-night delivery gap in inner Sydney. The pizza is reliable rather than remarkable — good base, decent toppings, arrives in reasonable shape. For those times when it’s 9:30pm and you want pizza delivered within 40 minutes, Epic is a solid call.
Best for: late-night orders, reliability over artisanship, inner-city delivery coverage.
Quick Comparison: Best Pizza Sydney at a Glance
Not sure which one suits your situation? Here’s the summary:
| Pizza Place | Style | Delivery | Dine-In | Group Catering | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Made In Italy ⭐ | Roman XL | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | Best overall, delivery, catering |
| Via Napoli | Neapolitan | – | ✓ | – | Purist Neapolitan, dine-in |
| Matteo’s Pizza | Wood-Fired | – | ✓ | – | Neighbourhood locals |
| Fratelli Fresh | Roman | – | ✓ | ✓ | Full Italian spread, groups |
| A Slice of Italy | Roman by-the-slice | – | – | – | Quick lunch, single slice |
| Criniti’s | American-Italian | – | ✓ | ✓ | Large groups, big occasions |
| Epic Pizza | Classic | ✓ | – | – | Late-night delivery |
Roman Style vs Neapolitan — Which Should You Choose?
Sydney’s pizza debate often comes down to these two styles. Here’s the short version:
Roman-style pizza (what Made In Italy specialises in) has a thinner, crispier base that holds toppings without going soggy. It’s baked at a lower temperature for longer, which gives the base a more complex flavour. The crust is firm enough to eat without a knife and fork. Roman pizza also travels well — it arrives in almost the same condition it left the kitchen, which is why it’s the dominant delivery style.
Neapolitan pizza is cooked at very high temperatures (400°C+) for 60–90 seconds. The result is a charred, puffy crust and a softer, wetter centre. It’s beautiful in a restaurant but tends to soften on delivery. Best experienced fresh from the oven at a dine-in venue.
If you’re ordering delivery or feeding a group: Roman style wins. If you’re dining in and want a traditional Neapolitan experience: go Neapolitan.
Frequently Asked Questions: Best Pizza in Sydney
What is the best pizza in Sydney right now?
Made In Italy consistently tops local lists for best pizza in Sydney — particularly for delivery and group orders. Their Roman-style XL pizzas have been made to the same recipe since 2000, using slow-cooked sauces and real Italian ingredients. For dine-in with a Neapolitan focus, Via Napoli is the other top pick.
Which pizza place in Sydney is best for delivery?
Made In Italy is the strongest delivery option in Sydney. Roman-style pizza holds its quality during transit far better than Neapolitan-style, and Made In Italy delivers to a wide range of inner Sydney suburbs including Alexandria, Annandale, Pyrmont, Surry Hills, Newtown, Glebe, and the CBD. Free delivery applies on orders over $50.
What is the best pizza in Sydney CBD?
For the Sydney CBD, Made In Italy’s York Lane location (near Wynyard Station) is the go-to for delivery and takeaway. They also handle corporate catering across the CBD for office lunches and events. For dine-in in the CBD, Fratelli Fresh is worth considering for larger groups.
What’s the difference between Roman and Neapolitan pizza in Sydney?
Roman-style pizza (like Made In Italy) has a thin, crispy base baked at a moderate temperature — it’s firm, holds toppings well, and travels well for delivery. Neapolitan pizza is baked at very high heat for under 90 seconds, producing a puffy, charred crust with a softer wet centre — best eaten fresh in a restaurant. Made In Italy specialises in Roman-style XL round pizzas using original recipes from Rome.
Is there good pizza near me in Sydney’s inner west?
Yes. Made In Italy’s Annandale and Alexandria locations cover most of the inner west — including Newtown, Glebe, Leichhardt, Enmore, Marrickville, Stanmore, Petersham, and surrounding suburbs. Check the delivery area at madeinitaly.com.au or order directly from the online store.
Which Sydney pizza place is best for catering?
Made In Italy handles catering for groups from 10 to 200+ people across Sydney. They deliver pizza and pasta trays to offices, homes, and events, with free delivery on catering orders over $50. Popular choices for catering include the Americana pizza, the Bolognese pasta (slow-cooked 4 hours), and mixed platters. See the catering page for details.
More from Made In Italy
Looking for something more specific? These pages cover our locations, menus, and delivery areas:
- Italian Restaurant Sydney CBD — delivery, takeaway and corporate catering from York Lane, Wynyard
- Italian Restaurant Alexandria — dine-in, delivery and takeaway from our Alexandria flagship
- Italian Restaurant Annandale — inner west dining and delivery hub
- Pizza Delivery Sydney — full inner Sydney delivery coverage and delivery zones
- Italian Catering Sydney — pizza and pasta catering for offices, events, and private functions