Best Pizza in Sydney: 10 Spots Worth the Trip (2026)
Table of Contents
- What Makes Sydney Pizza Worth Talking About?
- Roman vs Neapolitan: Which Style Wins?
- The 10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Sydney
- Best Pizza Delivery in Sydney
- Best Pizza Sydney CBD Specifically
- FAQ: Best Pizza Sydney
What Makes Sydney Pizza Worth Talking About?
Sydney’s pizza scene has grown up. A decade ago the city was still stuck in a “gourmet topping” phase — BBQ chicken on thick, bland bases passed as Italian. That era is over.
Today the best pizza restaurants in Sydney draw on specific regional traditions: Neapolitan, Roman, Sicilian, New York. Each style has its own rules. The best spots in Sydney pick a lane and commit. The worst try to be everything and end up as nothing.
This guide covers the 10 best pizza restaurants in Sydney in 2026, ranked by style authenticity, consistency, and value. Whether you’re after a sit-down dinner in Surry Hills, a quick CBD lunch, or pizza delivery to your inner west apartment, there’s a spot here for you.
Roman vs Neapolitan: Which Style Wins?
Before the list — a quick distinction most Sydney pizza guides skip.
Neapolitan pizza is soft, wet-centred, char-spotted, cooked in a wood-fired oven at 450°C+ for 60-90 seconds. Thin at the base, puffy at the crust. The Margherita at its purest.
Roman pizza is thin, crispy, and dry all the way through. Cooked at lower temperatures for longer. The base holds its structure — no floppy centres, no soggy edges. It travels better, cuts cleaner, and feeds more people per pizza. The XL format (14-15 inches) is a Roman-style thing.
Both are worth eating. They’re just different food. Most Sydney pizza debates conflate the two — which is like arguing whether a baguette is better than sourdough.
The 10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Sydney
1. Made In Italy — CBD, Pyrmont, Annandale, Alexandria
Style: Roman | Best for: CBD lunch, group delivery, inner west dine-in
Made In Italy has been making Roman-style pizza in Sydney since 2000 — which makes it one of the longest-running Italian restaurants in the city. Four locations across the CBD, Pyrmont, Annandale, and Alexandria. The pizza is hand-stretched, thin, and crispy with a proper char on the base. No floppy centres.
The XL 15-inch format is the signature — designed for sharing, with half-and-half available. The 12-hour slow-cooked pasta sauces are worth ordering alongside. The Lamb Ragu in particular is the kind of thing you plan a trip around.
The $18 lunch specials Tuesday to Friday at York Lane in the CBD make this the most affordable sit-down Italian lunch in the city centre. For delivery, Made In Italy covers most of inner Sydney from four kitchens — check if they deliver to your suburb here.
Where: 37 York Lane, Sydney CBD | 104 Miller St, Pyrmont | Annandale | Alexandria
Order online: madeinitaly.com.au
2. Bella Brutta — Newtown
Style: Contemporary | Best for: Creative toppings, natural wine pairings
Bella Brutta on King Street has built a loyal following on unconventional combinations — fennel sausage, calabrian chilli, stracciatella. The base is somewhere between Roman and Neapolitan: thin but with a slight chew. The natural wine list is one of the better ones attached to a pizza restaurant in Sydney.
Where: 157 King Street, Newtown
3. Via Napoli — Surry Hills & Lane Cove
Style: Neapolitan | Best for: Traditional wood-fired, awards recognition
Via Napoli is the Neapolitan benchmark in Sydney. Luigi Esposito’s restaurant has earned a place in the Top 50 Pizzerias in the World — a significant achievement. The DOC Margherita (San Marzano tomatoes, fior di latte, fresh basil) is close to what you’d eat in Naples.
Where: Surry Hills & Lane Cove
4. Vacanza — Surry Hills & Bronte
Style: Contemporary Neapolitan | Best for: Surry Hills dinner, groups
Vacanza regularly tops Sydney pizza polls. It’s a crowded restaurant that runs efficiently — the pizza comes fast and the room turns over quickly. The bases are soft and well-charred. Service is casual and quick. Good for a Friday night when you don’t want a two-hour meal.
Where: Surry Hills & Bronte
5. Lucio Pizzeria — Darlinghurst
Style: Neapolitan | Best for: Date night, classic Italian atmosphere
One of Sydney’s most consistent Neapolitan spots. Lucio has been on Victoria Street long enough to qualify as an institution. The Diavola — salami, chilli, fior di latte — is a reliable order. The room is small and gets loud on weekends.
Where: Darlinghurst
6. Da Mario — Rosebery
Style: Traditional Italian | Best for: Simple, well-executed classics
Da Mario in Rosebery keeps things deliberately simple. The toppings are restrained, the base is consistent, the room is comfortable. No gimmicks. For people who find the current wave of experimental pizza tiring, Da Mario is the antidote.
Where: Rosebery
7. Rosso Pomodoro — Various
Style: Neapolitan-inspired | Best for: Families, multiple Sydney locations
Rosso Pomodoro has built a consistent formula across multiple Sydney locations. Not the most exciting pizza on this list, but reliable and family-friendly. Good value for the price point.
Where: Multiple Sydney locations
8. Dimitri’s Pizzeria — Glebe
Style: Classic Australian-Italian | Best for: Local neighbourhood staple
Dimitri’s has been in Glebe long enough that regulars treat it as their dining room. The style is classic Australian-Italian — not trying to be Neapolitan, not pretending to be contemporary. It just makes good pizza at a fair price for a suburb that knows its food.
Where: Glebe
9. Pizza Madre — Surry Hills
Style: Sourdough | Best for: Sourdough base enthusiasts
Pizza Madre builds its bases on long-fermented sourdough, which gives the crust a distinctive tang and open crumb. The toppings lean seasonal and local. Not traditional Italian but interesting and consistent.
Where: Surry Hills
10. Al Taglio — CBD
Style: Roman by-the-slice | Best for: Quick lunch, grab-and-go CBD
Al Taglio does Roman-style pizza by the slice — sold by weight, fresh out of the oven throughout the day. The by-the-slice format is far more common in Rome than Sydney, and Al Taglio does it well. Good for a fast CBD lunch when you don’t have time to sit down.
Where: Sydney CBD
Best Pizza Delivery in Sydney
Most of the restaurants on this list do not deliver. For pizza delivery across Sydney, the options narrow quickly.
Made In Italy covers the widest delivery area in inner Sydney — from four kitchens in the CBD, Pyrmont, Annandale, and Alexandria. The full menu is available for delivery every evening: XL Roman pizza, 12-hour slow-cooked pasta, salads, and desserts. Free delivery on orders over $50.
Check delivery suburbs and order online here.
For third-party delivery platforms (DoorDash, Uber Eats), several restaurants on this list are available — though wait times and quality on delivery vary significantly from the dine-in experience.
Best Pizza Sydney CBD Specifically
The CBD narrows the field considerably. Most of Sydney’s best pizza restaurants are in the inner west or eastern suburbs, not the city centre.
For the CBD specifically, the options are:
- Made In Italy York Lane — the most established Italian restaurant in the CBD, open for lunch and dinner, with $18 lunch specials Tuesday to Friday
- Al Taglio — by-the-slice Roman pizza, great for fast lunches
- Delivery options — Made In Italy delivers across the CBD grid from their York Lane kitchen every evening
For office groups and corporate catering in the CBD, Made In Italy’s pizza and pasta catering service is the most used by Sydney offices — XL pizza platters and pasta trays delivered to your floor.
FAQ: Best Pizza Sydney
What is the best pizza in Sydney?
The best pizza in Sydney depends on style. For Roman-style thin and crispy: Made In Italy (CBD, Pyrmont, Annandale, Alexandria) — hand-stretched, XL, and available since 2000. For Neapolitan wood-fired: Via Napoli (Surry Hills), which holds a place in the world’s Top 50 Pizzerias. For creative contemporary: Bella Brutta (Newtown).
Where is the best pizza in Sydney CBD?
Made In Italy at 37 York Lane (near Wynyard Station) is the standout CBD Italian restaurant. Roman-style pizza since 2000, $18 lunch specials Tuesday to Friday, and free delivery across the CBD on orders over $50.
What is Roman-style pizza?
Roman-style pizza is thin, crispy, and dry all the way through — unlike Neapolitan, which is soft and wet-centred. It is cooked at lower temperatures for longer, holds its structure when cut, and works well in the XL format (14-15 inches) for sharing. Made In Italy specialises in this style.
Does Made In Italy deliver pizza across Sydney?
Yes. Made In Italy delivers from four kitchens across inner Sydney — CBD, Pyrmont, Annandale, and Alexandria. Free delivery on orders over $50. Check your suburb here.
What is the cheapest pizza lunch in Sydney CBD?
Made In Italy’s $18 lunch specials (any medium pizza or pasta, Tuesday to Friday, 11am-2pm) are the best value sit-down Italian lunch in the Sydney CBD. Available at their York Lane restaurant near Wynyard.
Is wood-fired pizza better than Roman-style?
Neither is objectively better — they are different products. Wood-fired Neapolitan pizza is soft, wet-centred and fast-cooked. Roman-style pizza is thin, crispy, and slow-cooked. The “best” depends on personal preference. Both styles have excellent representations in Sydney.
Made In Italy has been serving Roman-style pizza in Sydney since 2000. Four restaurants in the CBD, Pyrmont, Annandale, and Alexandria. Dine in, takeaway, or free delivery on orders over $50.